Integrity Magazine – S.D. Wright responds to Bishop Schneider’s case against ‘sedevacantism’ in Ad Vaticanum interview

On October 29, 2026, Bishop Athanasius Schneider — auxiliary bishop of Astana, Kazakshstan, and favorite of conservatives and would-be traditionalists — gave a wide-ranging interview to Ad Vaticanum’s Niwa Limbu. In the course of this interview, Limbu asked the bishop to explain why “sedevacantism” is wrong. “Sedevacantism” is the conclusion that the Holy See has been vacant (or at least only “materially” occupied) since the Second Vatican Council. 1 Unfortunately, Bishop Schneider’s answer was full of caricatures, misconceptions and exaggerations — the point of objectively containing falsehoods.


Originally published in Integrity Magazine. Read original article

Original Tags: Vatican II, Bishop Schneider, Sedevacantism, Theology, Traditional Catholicism