WM Review – Can the Pope teach ex cathedra in a letter to a single bishop? Fr Palmieri explains

Pope Hormisdas. By Giovanni Battista de’Cavalieri – This file was uploaded by Biblioteca comunale di Trento., CC0. As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases through our Amazon links. See also The WM Review Shop.
The answer is YES – if it is clear that he is exercising his authority as the Supreme Pastor, and defining a doctrine to be held by all.

Editor’s Notes

In the course of considering a number texts from Fr Domenico Palmieri relevant to the “recognise and resist” movement, we published the nineteenth century theologian’s treatments of the “Heretic Pope” question, and of the authority of non-infallible teaching acts.Both those texts were scholia to Thesis XXXII, which we reproduce below.


Originally published in The WM Review. Read original article