For nearly two decades, the Transalpine Redemptorists of Papa Stronsay were presented as the model of “traditionalism in full communion.” Founded in the orbit of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, regularized under Benedict XVI, and canonically recognized as the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer, they were held up as proof that one could preserve Tradition while remaining peacefully inside the post-conciliar structure.>That experiment has now publicly collapsed. In their May 2026 declaration, The Dogma to Steer By, following their explosive October 2025 Open Letter, the monks have effectively crossed the line into a sedevacantist position: the post-conciliar claimants, they correctly argue, have imposed a religion incompatible with Catholic dogma, and Catholics cannot obey commands destructive of the Faith. The practical conclusion is unmistakable: the authority claiming to govern the Church is not functioning as Catholic authority at all.>Keep in mind that this is not the rhetoric of anonymous internet polemicists but the conclusion of a religious congregation that spent years trying to make “recognize and resist” work from inside the system.

Originally published in Radical Fidelity. Read original article